"Melissa just sold our property and did a wonderful job! She is hard working, highly professional and very straight forward in her communication. Selling a home can be a stressful experience and dealing with Melissa made it enjoyable! Aside from being highly skilled in her trade, she is a nice person and fun to work with! I would highly recommend Melissa for any of your residential real estate needs!"
"Melissa just sold our property and did a wonderful job! She is hard working, highly professional and very straight forward in her communication. Selling a home can be a stressful experience and dealing with Melissa made it enjoyable! Aside from being highly skilled in her trade, she is a nice person and fun to work with! I would highly recommend Melissa for any of your residential real estate needs!"
Kyle Hansen
"I found Melissa by asking ChatGPT who is the best realtor in the western Wisconsin area. It was not wrong. Melissa sold our house in less than 30 days, even after the first buyer's financing fell through and we had to find another buyer. She is the best. If she has the bandwidth to take you on as a client, do it."
"I found Melissa by asking ChatGPT who is the best realtor in the western Wisconsin area. It was not wrong. Melissa sold our house in less than 30 days, even after the first buyer's financing fell through and we had to find another buyer. She is the best. If she has the bandwidth to take you on as a client, do it."
Antoni Grgurovic
"We worked with Alison to both sell our home and purchase a new one, and overall had a really positive experience. She was very attentive throughout the process and always quick to respond, which made a stressful time feel much more manageable.
One thing we especially appreciated was the effort she put into staging our home. It looked great and really showed well, which made a noticeable difference.
She is knowledgeable, organized, and clearly experienced in what she does. If you’re looking for someone who is responsive, hands-on, and will keep things moving, she’s a solid choice.
"
"We worked with Alison to both sell our home and purchase a new one, and overall had a really positive experience. She was very attentive throughout the process and always quick to respond, which made a stressful time feel much more manageable.
One thing we especially appreciated was the effort she put into staging our home. It looked great and really showed well, which made a noticeable difference.
She is knowledgeable, organized, and clearly experienced in what she does. If you’re looking for someone who is responsive, hands-on, and will keep things moving, she’s a solid choice.
"
Laura Raseman White
"Melissa is fabulous to work with! She knows the market and gives an honest estimate of home value, so your listing moves quickly and doesn't sit on the market for months. Her staff is very responsive. Would definitely recommend Melissa for buying or selling!"
"Melissa is fabulous to work with! She knows the market and gives an honest estimate of home value, so your listing moves quickly and doesn't sit on the market for months. Her staff is very responsive. Would definitely recommend Melissa for buying or selling!"
Bonnie O.
"Melissa and her Team were very proactive, communicative, and professional throughout the entire process. Melissa responded quickly and completely to all of our questions regarding the sale of our home."
"Melissa and her Team were very proactive, communicative, and professional throughout the entire process. Melissa responded quickly and completely to all of our questions regarding the sale of our home."
Andrew Fenn
"When searching for a home, Alison truly took the time to listen to our wants and needs. She offered thoughtful, informed perspectives while always leaving the final decisions to us, which we greatly appreciated. Once we found our home, she kept us consistently informed and up to date throughout the process—we always knew what needed to be done and when. Whenever possible, she even coordinated tasks on our behalf, making everything feel seamless.
Alison was very flexible in how she communicated, adapting to the tools that worked best for us—text, notes, and email. During the selling process, she was instrumental in ensuring our home showed beautifully, from styling beds to making small décor tweaks that made a big difference. Working with Alison was an absolute pleasure; she made the entire experience easy, smooth, and genuinely fun."
"When searching for a home, Alison truly took the time to listen to our wants and needs. She offered thoughtful, informed perspectives while always leaving the final decisions to us, which we greatly appreciated. Once we found our home, she kept us consistently informed and up to date throughout the process—we always knew what needed to be done and when. Whenever possible, she even coordinated tasks on our behalf, making everything feel seamless.
Alison was very flexible in how she communicated, adapting to the tools that worked best for us—text, notes, and email. During the selling process, she was instrumental in ensuring our home showed beautifully, from styling beds to making small décor tweaks that made a big difference. Working with Alison was an absolute pleasure; she made the entire experience easy, smooth, and genuinely fun."
Kelsey Halberg
"Ashley was nothing short of outstanding! From the initial meeting all the way to closing. Her communication was responsive, clear, and defined every step of the journey. She outlined options and helped us make decisions that stuck close to our gut and our heart. She was very caring and supportive in selling our childhood home for our mom. A very professional and loving experience overall. Thank you, Ashley!"
"Ashley was nothing short of outstanding! From the initial meeting all the way to closing. Her communication was responsive, clear, and defined every step of the journey. She outlined options and helped us make decisions that stuck close to our gut and our heart. She was very caring and supportive in selling our childhood home for our mom. A very professional and loving experience overall. Thank you, Ashley!"
Stephanie L.
"Melissa and her team working behind the scenes was great. Best experience I've had selling a home."
"Melissa and her team working behind the scenes was great. Best experience I've had selling a home."
Kim Wylie
"In the past six months, we’ve worked with Melissa Wiegele twice—first to sell a house through probate and later to purchase a new home. This gave me the opportunity to review her services as both a seller’s and buyer’s agent, and I couldn’t be more impressed. Going through the probate process, she was able to help us navigate the process; she even knew our probate lawyer, which made communication easy. This isn’t just a one-time coincidence—choosing Melissa means gaining access to her extensive network of professionals, I’m certain as a write more I will list more. Melissa also invests in the latest technology to ensure your listing gets maximum visibility. Our home was prominently featured on major real estate websites, boosted for visibility, and priced competitively (I felt like I had all the bells and whistles). Thanks to her strategy, we had an offer within a day of showings, and the sale was as straightforward as we could have hoped for. I can’t promise you will sell your house in a day, but this was my experience. When we decided to buy a new home, calling Melissa again was an obvious choice. While I had multiple pre-approvals from lenders, she suggested I contact someone from her trusted network (she even has a book with great business partners). This turned out to be a game-changer. Any time I had a question—often outside regular business hours—either Melissa or the lender was immediately available to assist. Their responsiveness and support eliminated much of the stress that can come with buying a home. Often, you have a random question, and not having to wait until the morning or through the weekend was such a comfort. What truly sets Melissa apart is her commitment to her clients. She’s not just looking for a quick commission. Melissa understands that providing an exceptional experience builds lasting relationships and leads to referrals and repeat business. She always kept our best interests in mind, offering honest, experienced advice—even if it wasn’t necessarily what we wanted to hear. She’s a true partner in the process, not just someone to unlock doors or post a “For Sale” sign. My experience with Melissa was so outstanding that I’m taking the time to write this review, hoping to pay it forward a bit. If you’re looking for someone knowledgeable, trustworthy, and committed to making your real estate experience smooth and successful, I recommend Melissa. She’s a rockstar."
"In the past six months, we’ve worked with Melissa Wiegele twice—first to sell a house through probate and later to purchase a new home. This gave me the opportunity to review her services as both a seller’s and buyer’s agent, and I couldn’t be more impressed. Going through the probate process, she was able to help us navigate the process; she even knew our probate lawyer, which made communication easy. This isn’t just a one-time coincidence—choosing Melissa means gaining access to her extensive network of professionals, I’m certain as a write more I will list more. Melissa also invests in the latest technology to ensure your listing gets maximum visibility. Our home was prominently featured on major real estate websites, boosted for visibility, and priced competitively (I felt like I had all the bells and whistles). Thanks to her strategy, we had an offer within a day of showings, and the sale was as straightforward as we could have hoped for. I can’t promise you will sell your house in a day, but this was my experience. When we decided to buy a new home, calling Melissa again was an obvious choice. While I had multiple pre-approvals from lenders, she suggested I contact someone from her trusted network (she even has a book with great business partners). This turned out to be a game-changer. Any time I had a question—often outside regular business hours—either Melissa or the lender was immediately available to assist. Their responsiveness and support eliminated much of the stress that can come with buying a home. Often, you have a random question, and not having to wait until the morning or through the weekend was such a comfort. What truly sets Melissa apart is her commitment to her clients. She’s not just looking for a quick commission. Melissa understands that providing an exceptional experience builds lasting relationships and leads to referrals and repeat business. She always kept our best interests in mind, offering honest, experienced advice—even if it wasn’t necessarily what we wanted to hear. She’s a true partner in the process, not just someone to unlock doors or post a “For Sale” sign. My experience with Melissa was so outstanding that I’m taking the time to write this review, hoping to pay it forward a bit. If you’re looking for someone knowledgeable, trustworthy, and committed to making your real estate experience smooth and successful, I recommend Melissa. She’s a rockstar."
Tom P.
"Ashley Stohl is the best real estate agent I’ve encountered, and Coldwell Banker Realty handled our transaction smoothly.
I’ve never considered real estate agents worthwhile until working with Ashley Stohl. Ashley asked and listened with care to my wife and me to find out what each of us wanted in a new home. She researched potential homes in our price range, she escorted us through showings of houses, she advised us what factors to consider, she kept us thoroughly informed throughout our home search, she found homes that met both my wife’s and my own wants, and she actually saved us $10,000 on the purchase of our dream home.
These are difficult times for home buyers, but Ashley found the right home in the right location, and we were both quite anxious to buy the home. After the showing, we were going to offer significantly more money than the home was worth. Ashley helped us talk through the numbers before she drafted our offer and we decided to lower our bid by $10,000. She also protected us by recommending we include a clause in the purchase offer that voided the offer if the home did not appraise for what we offered. The sellers accepted our conditional offer and we ended up buying our dream home knowing it was worth it."
"Ashley Stohl is the best real estate agent I’ve encountered, and Coldwell Banker Realty handled our transaction smoothly.
I’ve never considered real estate agents worthwhile until working with Ashley Stohl. Ashley asked and listened with care to my wife and me to find out what each of us wanted in a new home. She researched potential homes in our price range, she escorted us through showings of houses, she advised us what factors to consider, she kept us thoroughly informed throughout our home search, she found homes that met both my wife’s and my own wants, and she actually saved us $10,000 on the purchase of our dream home.
These are difficult times for home buyers, but Ashley found the right home in the right location, and we were both quite anxious to buy the home. After the showing, we were going to offer significantly more money than the home was worth. Ashley helped us talk through the numbers before she drafted our offer and we decided to lower our bid by $10,000. She also protected us by recommending we include a clause in the purchase offer that voided the offer if the home did not appraise for what we offered. The sellers accepted our conditional offer and we ended up buying our dream home knowing it was worth it."
Rick L.
"Aliyah has always been present with any question or concern that we had about a property or about the home buying & selling process. She is timely in responding to us and very professional in handling her duties as a realtor. Moreover, she was simply a joy to work with in this sometimes stressful and emotional process. Thank you Aliyah!
"
"Aliyah has always been present with any question or concern that we had about a property or about the home buying & selling process. She is timely in responding to us and very professional in handling her duties as a realtor. Moreover, she was simply a joy to work with in this sometimes stressful and emotional process. Thank you Aliyah!
"
Dean Jensen
"Melissa did a fantastic job selling our home/horse farm. Her experience and knowledge were obvious. She has exceptional communication skills and is super easy to work with. We would recommend her to anyone looking for excellent results when selling their property."
"Melissa did a fantastic job selling our home/horse farm. Her experience and knowledge were obvious. She has exceptional communication skills and is super easy to work with. We would recommend her to anyone looking for excellent results when selling their property."
Julie G.
"Melissa was incredibly helpful and supportive throughout this entire house-hunting and purchase process. She is extremely knowledgeable and was always available to view homes, answer questions, and help navigate the closing process. We purchased this home remotely, and her guidance and support were invaluable. The entire home-purchase experience, which was new to us, was more comfortable because of Melissa."
"Melissa was incredibly helpful and supportive throughout this entire house-hunting and purchase process. She is extremely knowledgeable and was always available to view homes, answer questions, and help navigate the closing process. We purchased this home remotely, and her guidance and support were invaluable. The entire home-purchase experience, which was new to us, was more comfortable because of Melissa."
James B.
"Melissa was great to work with! Answered all of my questions, gave me more than enough information in order to make good decisions, and helped make the whole process of selling my house so smooth! Update: my partner and I went to Melissa again to purchase a house, and once again, she's been amazing to work with. I can't recommend her enough. She is knowledgeable and honest, she's responsive to all of our questions, and all around made the entire process incredibly easy."
"Melissa was great to work with! Answered all of my questions, gave me more than enough information in order to make good decisions, and helped make the whole process of selling my house so smooth! Update: my partner and I went to Melissa again to purchase a house, and once again, she's been amazing to work with. I can't recommend her enough. She is knowledgeable and honest, she's responsive to all of our questions, and all around made the entire process incredibly easy."
Anna Z.
"Melissa is fantastic to work with. She is well organized, thoughtful, and straightforward, and she made this process very manageable. She listens to your needs and puts a lot of thought into the strategy for selling your house, then provides you with a written presentation of her strategy that is customized for you. She found answers to all of my questions and provided valuable guidance along the way. It was a pleasure getting to know her."
"Melissa is fantastic to work with. She is well organized, thoughtful, and straightforward, and she made this process very manageable. She listens to your needs and puts a lot of thought into the strategy for selling your house, then provides you with a written presentation of her strategy that is customized for you. She found answers to all of my questions and provided valuable guidance along the way. It was a pleasure getting to know her."
Carol A.
"Melissa and her team are top-notch and the best in the business! Melissa does such an amazing job. Helps you with all your questions and calms you when you are nervous. Her expertise is unmatched! I would recommend her to anyone looking for a top-notch, knowledgeable, and honest realtor!"
"Melissa and her team are top-notch and the best in the business! Melissa does such an amazing job. Helps you with all your questions and calms you when you are nervous. Her expertise is unmatched! I would recommend her to anyone looking for a top-notch, knowledgeable, and honest realtor!"
Jill B.
"The whole experience from beginning to end was very smooth and non-stressful, which is rare when purchasing a home. Melissa is wonderful to work with and extremely helpful; additionally, she went out of her way to make it easier for me during the purchasing and initial moving process. She is hands down the best agent I've ever worked with for purchasing a home!"
"The whole experience from beginning to end was very smooth and non-stressful, which is rare when purchasing a home. Melissa is wonderful to work with and extremely helpful; additionally, she went out of her way to make it easier for me during the purchasing and initial moving process. She is hands down the best agent I've ever worked with for purchasing a home!"
Alana D.
"We recently purchased a home from Melissa and her team, and could not recommend them more. Lindsay was extremely kind and helpful. We couldn’t recommend Lindsay and Melissa enough. They provide quality help and are truly the best in the area. We felt Lindsay went above and beyond to make sure we were happy in our home. We will definitely be recommending it to everyone and using it again!"
"We recently purchased a home from Melissa and her team, and could not recommend them more. Lindsay was extremely kind and helpful. We couldn’t recommend Lindsay and Melissa enough. They provide quality help and are truly the best in the area. We felt Lindsay went above and beyond to make sure we were happy in our home. We will definitely be recommending it to everyone and using it again!"
Sierra H.
"It was a pleasure working with Melissa on my client’s recent home purchase. She was responsive, professional, and worked diligently to ensure a seamless transaction. I look forward to working together again in the future!"
"It was a pleasure working with Melissa on my client’s recent home purchase. She was responsive, professional, and worked diligently to ensure a seamless transaction. I look forward to working together again in the future!"
Allison L.
